I think a lot of non-atheists are confused about what atheism even
is. I've already talked about
the agnosticism fallacy; that's not what concerns me today. What concerns me today is not believing in God.
Part of the
reason this concerns me is that atheists are
America's most hated minority (and that we, along with
only children, are among the least acknowledgedly shat-upon people in our society)—but that's not going to be the focus right now. The focus right now is going to be on two simple facts, facts that
should be simple, which I'm going to hit as succinctly as I can:
(1) atheism isn't about God being a jerk, and
(2) atheism isn't about not believing in anything.
(1) Way more often than I can really comprehend, I hear people suggest that not only
a but
the reason why people are atheists is that they can't understand why God would allow the Holocaust to happen, or car crashes to happen, or cancer to happen, etc., etc. Guess what? First of all, there is no logical problem there: if God exists, why couldn't He be capable of doing shitty things? Indeed, the Bible itself suggests that God is emotional, irrational, spiteful, wrathful, violent, "jealous," and extremely dangerous. (The reason why "God hates fags" is so offensive is not that it's inconceivable that the God of the Bible might dislike gay people: He seems to hate an awful lot of people for an awful lot of reasons!) Second of all, and more importantly—new paragraph for this, even—
—the reason why people don't believe in God is that
they don't believe in God. To be perfectly frank (and, to some, offensive), belief in God is like belief in Santa Claus: some people (usually small children, in Santa's case) take it totally for granted, and other people take for granted that it's
false. Your average atheist isn't an atheist because he thinks God is mean. Your average atheist is an atheist because he thinks God is a fairy tale.
Put it this way: being an atheist because of pain and suffering is like being a lesbian because men are scum. The only good reason to be a lesbian is that you're attracted to women, and the only good reason to be an atheist is that you don't believe in God.
 |
| Not what it's about. |
(2) Maybe if you can understand that atheists just plain don't believe in God—not out of spite, but out of what, just to gesture toward diplomacy, I'll say they
believe to be
simple clear-headed rationality (and nonbrainwashedness: brainfilthiness, if you must)—you can also see that atheism does not imply immorality or amorality or unmorality or anything of the sort. Maybe you can understand that atheism implies that morality, since it exists, must have a source
other than God.
Even if you disagree, even if you think that God does exist and atheists are mistaken or even satanically misled, can't you see how, hypothetically,
if God didn't exist, then humankind's sense of morality must have originated somewhere
other than God? I'm not asking you to agree: I'm asking you to imagine. Imagine a world in which God did not exist. Morality still exists as a concept, yes? Where did it come from if God doesn't exist? FROM HUMANITY.
The morality of an atheist is the morality of a person who believes that the God who gave us moral laws is essentially—forgive me for the metaphor here—a Muppet: when Kermit the Frog sings "The Rainbow Connection," we (I should hope) understand that actually that's the voice of Jim Henson and that Kermit himself is a puppet; similarly,
from the atheist's perspective, the morality you attribute to God and divinity, an atheist will attribute to the human imagination that
created God and divinity. Again, I'm not asking you to accept this as true or agree, just to see that that's what an atheist believes. I'm asking you to understand that when someone says, "I'm an atheist," that is not synonymous with, "I believe nothing is true and nothing means anything."
Under "Religious Views" on Facebook, I wrote "Q*bert." This is partly a joke, but it is also partly (I recently recognized) because if I write, "Atheist," I know that many people will think, "Oh, he thinks everything is permissible," or, "Oh, he rejects morality." And I don't want people to think that. It hit me recently that this is cowardly—but cowardly in much the same way that it was cowardly for Jews in an anti-Semitic society (not a
violently anti-Semitic society, just a society that looks down on Jews) to pretend not to be Jewish. And the saddest part about this is that, even after recognizing this, I still didn't change it to
atheist—because I want to avoid that misunderstanding.
But I guess I did write this.
Again, I'm not asking religious people to become atheists (although it would be nice). I'm just asking religious people to recognize what atheism is, and what it is not. Think we're wrong, think our views are the result of satanic deception, think we're going to Hell—just don't think that what we mean when we say we don't believe in God is that we think bad is good, or that we're angry at God.
We just plum don't believe God exists.
While I'm making such reasonable and likely requests, let me also note that I would like $10 million and a house in the hills.